内容简介:TL;DR:When exporting data for general use, we in the industry are likely to reach for CSV files; they’re basically plain-text, but with a sort-of agreed-upon structure — well, there isFor most people, though, Excel sheets are what’s used and understood.
Faster Excel Parsing in Ruby
TL;DR: xsv was ~5 times faster than alternatives at parsing the XLSX file I benchmarked it against, and allocates the fewest objects . Meanwhile, roo allocates the least memory of benchmarked gems by a wide margin .
When exporting data for general use, we in the industry are likely to reach for CSV files; they’re basically plain-text, but with a sort-of agreed-upon structure — well, there is RFC 4180 but Wikipedia agrees that implementations are inconsistent at best.
For most people, though, Excel sheets are what’s used and understood. XLSX (aka OOXML) files have been the default file format in Microsoft Office for some years, replacing the proprietary XLS format of yore, and few will look beyond that. Excel sheets can contain considerably more complex information than CSVs, but due to their ubiquity and, perhaps, some level of ignorance, they’re commonly used to transfer simple collections of rows. Long story short: we’re tasked with offering Excel import options in our apps.
And yet, extracting simple data from XLSX files in Ruby is slow . The leading XLSX parser according to The Ruby Toolbox is rubyXL , which is not particularly fast at this task and can suck a ton of memory in the process. Now don’t get me wrong: rubyXL is awesome and can do a lot more than simply read XLSX files, but in most cases that’s all I need.
And my friend, Martijn , is in a similar situation: he just needs to parse simple user-uploaded XLSX sheets that users upload. So he wrote a gem optimized for parsing speed: xsv . I thought the idea was really interesting, so I wrote some simple benchmarks for popular gems capable of parsing these files and tabulated the results below.
The Benchmarks
Gem | Parses/second | Parses/hour | Allocated Memory | Retained Memory | Allocated Objects | Retained Objects | rubyXL | 0.129 | 463 | 934.014M | 1.973M | 14.413M | 20,215 |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
simple_xlsx_reader | 0.282 | 1,015 | 462.283M | 610.039k | 8.21M | 5,383 |
creek | 0.422 | 1,518 | 911.538M | 808.277k | 13.180M | 6,100 |
roo | 0.301 | 1,084 | 168.783M | 1.327M | 2.232M | 11,058 |
xsv | 1.531 | 5,510 | 347.250M | 362.540k | 1.506M | 3,166 |
Benchmarks were run on on a 2018 15-inch MacBook Pro with a 2.6GHz 6-Core Intel Core i7, 16 GB 2400MHz memory and MacOS Catalina 10.15.3. Ruby is 2.7.0, whilst the gem versions are:
- rubyXL 3.4.12
- simple_xslx_reader 1.0.4
- creek 2.5.0
- roo 2.8.3
- xsv 0.3.2
Spreadsheet can be found here , provided by the Dutch “Stichtse Vecht”.
I chose not to use the compare feature of benchmark-ips , instead opting to run each benchmark completely individually to ensure no side-effects.
The benchmark code can be found here . Though it’s not part of the codebase, I verified that each benchmark handles the same data by outputting the contents of each cell to a file and comparing the results via cmp .
If you find any errors, please make an issue or a PR.
The Summary
Speed-wise, the benchmarks speak for themselves: xsv is ~5 times faster than alternatives.
Regarding memory use, I’m no benchmarking expert so I’ll just quote Sam Saffron himself on memory metrics (from memory_profiler ):
Retained: long lived memory use and object count retained due to the execution of the code block. Allocated: All object allocation and memory allocation during code block.
roo does a great job in allocated memory, and there may be room for improvement in this area for xsv. Having said that, xsv does come second in memory allocation.
Don’t forget that xsv is only there to parse sheets; for writing and more advanced functionality, you’ll still need to reach for another tool.
Suggestions to improve xsv are welcome.
以上就是本文的全部内容,希望对大家的学习有所帮助,也希望大家多多支持 码农网
猜你喜欢:本站部分资源来源于网络,本站转载出于传递更多信息之目的,版权归原作者或者来源机构所有,如转载稿涉及版权问题,请联系我们。
国际游戏设计全教程
[美]迈克尔·萨蒙德 / 张然、赵嫣 / 中国青年出版社 / 2017-2 / 108.00元
你想成为一名电子游戏设计师吗?想知道《肯塔基0号路》《到家》《枪口》等独立游戏的制作理念及过程吗?想了解《戈莫布偶大冒险》《辐射3》《战争机器》中关卡设计的奥秘吗?本书用通俗易懂的文字介绍了在游戏开发与策划过程中,需要掌握的游戏设计原理和制作的基础知识,可以作为读者从“构思一个电子游戏”到“真正完成一个电子游戏”的完备指南。 本书以系统的游戏设计流程结合大量优秀的游戏设计案例进行讲解,让读者......一起来看看 《国际游戏设计全教程》 这本书的介绍吧!